Revisiting BetterTLS: Certificate Path Building

Netflix Technology Blog
22 min readintermediate
--
View Original

Overview

The article discusses the challenges and improvements in certificate path building within TLS implementations, particularly in light of recent certificate expirations that caused widespread issues. It highlights the importance of robust path building for maintaining trust in web PKI and introduces updates to BetterTLS, a tool designed to test TLS implementations against these challenges.

What You'll Learn

1

How to implement robust certificate path building in TLS applications

2

Why understanding certificate expiration is crucial for maintaining trust in web PKI

3

When to apply branching path building techniques to handle multiple certificate paths

Prerequisites & Requirements

  • Understanding of TLS and web PKI concepts
  • Familiarity with BetterTLS testing suite(optional)

Key Questions Answered

What are the common issues faced by TLS implementations in certificate path building?
TLS implementations often struggle with certificate path building, particularly when handling expired certificates or when clients do not recognize newer certificate authorities. This can lead to failures in establishing trust, as seen with the AddTrust and Let’s Encrypt certificate expirations.
How does BetterTLS improve TLS implementations?
BetterTLS introduces a suite of tests that evaluate TLS implementations on their ability to build certificate paths correctly and apply necessary validity checks. This includes checks for expired certificates, name constraints, and deprecated signing algorithms, ultimately enhancing the reliability of TLS connections.
What is the significance of the TLS 1.3 specification regarding certificate path building?
The TLS 1.3 specification allows for greater flexibility in certificate presentation, enabling servers to send multiple certificates to assist clients in building valid paths. This change is crucial for maintaining compatibility in a rapidly evolving web PKI ecosystem.

Technologies & Tools

Testing Suite
Bettertls
Used to evaluate TLS implementations for their certificate path building capabilities.
Protocol
TLS 1.3
The latest version of the TLS protocol that introduces flexibility in certificate handling.

Key Actionable Insights

1
Implement robust certificate path building in your TLS applications to ensure compatibility with evolving PKI standards.
As the web PKI ecosystem changes, applications that can adapt to new trust anchors and certificate paths will maintain secure connections and user trust.
2
Utilize the BetterTLS testing suite to evaluate your TLS implementation's path building capabilities.
Regular testing can help identify weaknesses in certificate handling, allowing developers to address issues before they impact users.
3
Stay informed about upcoming certificate expirations and their potential impact on your services.
Being proactive about certificate management can prevent service disruptions and maintain trust with users.

Common Pitfalls

1
Many TLS implementations fail to properly handle branching path building, leading to trust failures when certificates expire.
This often occurs because implementations treat path building and verification as separate processes, which can result in incomplete trust chains.
2
Ignoring the need for robust validation checks can leave applications vulnerable to security risks.
Without proper checks for expired certificates or deprecated algorithms, applications may inadvertently accept insecure connections.

Related Concepts

Certificate Authorities And Their Roles In Web Pki
The Impact Of Certificate Expiration On Service Reliability
Best Practices For Managing TLS Certificates